Bonfire Terminal vs Lumo by Proton
Lumo by Proton is a cloud-hosted personal assistant with strong privacy claims, no logs, no training, and zero-access encryption, running Mistral and Llama on freemium plans. Bonfire Terminal advances privacy differently: it keeps everything on your device with any provider key at cost and a one-time perpetual license.
Bonfire Terminal vs Lumo by Proton: the 16-factor comparison
| Rating factor | Lumo by Proton | Bonfire Terminal |
|---|---|---|
| Category | AI Personal Assistant | AI Terminal / Local Agent |
| Popularity | Not disclosed | Growing · indie |
| Hosting architecture | Cloud-Hosted | On-Device Local |
| Licensing model | Freemium | One-Time Perpetual |
| Data / training policy | No logs; no training; zero-access encryption | Fully local — nothing leaves device |
| Offline capability | No | Yes |
| Pricing tier range | $0 / Proton paid | One-time license |
| Execution unit cost | Subscription | Unlimited Local Compute |
| API-key markup | N/A | No — BYO key at cost |
| Supported LLM providers | Mistral;Meta/Llama | OpenAI; Anthropic; Google; Local; Any |
| Auth / permission types | Username-Password | API Key; Local/None |
| Phone / messaging bridges | None | Telegram; WhatsApp |
| Speech recognition engine | None | Whisper (local) |
| Local media processing | Partial | Yes |
| Sovereign score | 43 / 100 | 93 / 100 |
The sovereignty gap
Where Lumo by Proton lands on each weighted pillar (its bar) — the red marker is Bonfire's score. Auto-derived from the 16 factors above.
Which should you choose?
Choose Lumo by Proton if…
Choose Lumo by Proton if you want a privacy-focused cloud assistant with zero-access encryption backed by Proton's reputation.
Choose Bonfire Terminal if…
Choose Bonfire Terminal if you want data to physically stay on-device, any provider at cost, and a perpetual license instead of a subscription.
Bonfire Terminal vs Lumo by Proton: FAQ
Is Lumo by Proton private?
Lumo by Proton is notably private, with no logs, no training, and zero-access encryption, though it remains cloud-hosted so data is transmitted to be answered. Bonfire Terminal keeps processing on-device, so your data does not leave your machine at all.
Is Bonfire Terminal cheaper than Lumo by Proton?
Lumo is freemium, tied to Proton's paid plans. Bonfire Terminal is a one-time perpetual license with any LLM key at cost and no markup, so it can cost less over years than an ongoing Proton subscription.
Can Bonfire Terminal replace Lumo by Proton?
For a private personal assistant, yes, with even stronger locality. Lumo integrates with the Proton ecosystem, so if you rely on Proton Mail, Drive, and calendar ties, weigh that integration before switching to Bonfire Terminal.
What can Bonfire Terminal do that Lumo by Proton can't?
Bonfire Terminal runs on-device with any provider, Telegram and WhatsApp bridges, local Whisper speech recognition, and local media processing. Lumo is a cloud assistant limited to Mistral and Llama without those bridges or local capabilities.
How do I switch from Lumo by Proton to Bonfire Terminal?
Save any conversations you want from Lumo, install Bonfire Terminal, and add your own provider key. You trade a privacy-focused cloud assistant for a fully on-device agent under a one-time perpetual license.
Does Bonfire Terminal work offline vs Lumo by Proton?
Lumo by Proton has no offline capability as a cloud service. Bonfire Terminal runs locally and can handle on-device tasks like Whisper speech and media processing offline, while cloud LLM calls still require a connection.